July 14

Self-publishing Vs. Traditional Publishing: What's Right For You?

self publishing vs traditional

Recently, I’ve found myself chatting to several different people about the pros and cons of self-publishing. Having only ever self-published, and having not been “massively” successful thus far, I really have a limited personal view of the argument. For some genres, like children’s picture books, self-publishing is pretty much an act of love, whereas other genres can actually lead to far better returns for an author than traditional publishing.

Here’s what I have found to be true about self-publishing vs. traditional publishing,  so you can decide for yourself if one is better than the other for you, or even if a combination approach is the best way to get your book into the hands of ravenous readers.


If you have a book in your hands, ready to be published, you may be afraid to send it off to an agent or publisher in case it gets rejected, which, sadly, many books do. Again, and again, and again… The publishing industry likes for authors to be highly marketable. Your work has to rock hard, and you need to ideally have some sort of fan-base in place to prove that people actually like what you’ve written.

Because publishers are less likely to take a risk on an unknown quantity, you could face years of rejection, even if you are a really awesome writer with a solid best-seller on your hands. It’s just the way it is, but it doesn’t have to stop you from getting published.

Self-publishing is easy. In fact, some would argue that it’s too easy, because a glance at Amazon will show a glut of really crappy books by authors who throw up a few thousand words and a cheesy cover and call themselves authors. (Raises hand guiltily about the cheesy covers, but I stand by my short nonfiction, thank-you-very-much!) Do these less-than stellar books turn a profit? Some do. Many fail, while some aren’t really put up to turn a profit at all, but to help establish the author as an authority figure in their niche.

Self-publishing has made it possible for unknown authors to earn a very good living without the need for an agent or a publisher stepping in and taking most of the profits, and if you publish primarily in ebook form, your overhead is practically non-existent, meaning everything you earn in 100% profit.  Sounds good, doesn’t it?

So, if you, Joe Schmoe, want to publish your own book, it has every chance of being just as successful as a traditionally published book, but only if there are certain things in place to make that happen. Here’s the bit that many self-pubbers don’t want to hear. Unlike in traditional publishing, where you typically have a team of marketers, advertisers and other support team members in place to help push your book baby out into the big, wide world, self-publishing is just you. That’s it.

You have to learn how to market your books, price them competitively, promote them to the right people in the right places, and interact with your readers to establish a relationship that will help sell your books and build your “brand.”

Traditional publishing

What’s that you say? You are an artist, not a salesman? How can you possibly be expected to learn the dirty details of how to sell your darling books when you’re obviously the creative type, not the business type? Umm, after you get your head out of your own arse, please be advised that although traditional publishing may be the route for you, you’ll still need to learn some things about promoting your work. Authors are expected to do some work for sales, even if it’s less effort than going it alone.

If you long to be the next JK Rowling, staring lovingly at your books in all the bookstore window displays, traditional publishing can be a good way to make that happen. However, it’s not the only way. Self-published authors can still have their books distributed through major bookstores, but it takes (surprise, surprise) a little more effort.

To start with traditional publishing, you’ll need to find an agent willing to take you on. Depending on your book’s genre, you may be able to send in an unsolicited manuscript, even via email, and you might just get lucky enough to land an agent quickly. From there, your agent will deal with trying to get you accepted by a publishing house.

Both self-publishing and traditional publishing

Don’t freak out if you still haven’t figured out what you want to do. I mean, on one hand, you may have to learn a ton of new things, and your book still may not sell all that well, but you’ll have full control over the results. And, on the other hand, you could spend years waiting for a publisher to take on your book, and still earn far less than you realize.

There is a third alternative, and one that I have seen result in some really great results. Using a combination of both methods, or self-publishing first to build an audience, then use your newly-built platform to engage an agent and publisher, can be a very lucrative option for some authors. Who would have thought that John Grisham couldn’t get published at first? Not me, but it’s true. He self-published first, but kept trying with traditional publishers until one accepted him.

Whichever of the three methods you choose, there are some things you can do to help boost your chances of your book being a success. I’ll talk about these in a later post, in detail, but just know that regardless of how you’re published, you need to know how to get your book seen by the right audience, and you need to be your own biggest supporter.

How are you choosing to publish your next book? Please let me know in the comments below!

July 4

Lack of Information About Children's Paperback Book Marketing and Sales

roast potato potty potatoes books

So, this post took a while to get to the site. This is because I have been researching, studying, pulling my hair out and otherwise living the life of a self-published children’s book author these past few weeks. For those of you that don’t know, I am the author of the Potty Potatoes series of books for children. I didn’t plan on being a children’s picture book author (I can’t draw even a recognizable stick figure), but was approached by the creator and illustrator, Steve Scatcherd, a few years ago to write the books and help him bring the characters to life.

Now, let me be clear. I love writing these books. They are fun, my kids adore them, and it helps me feed my passion to inspire kids to read. BUT…it can be immensely frustrating at the same time, because for indie authors of kids’ picture books, it’s a constant struggle for sales and attention. There’s just not a lot of money in indie picture books; you do it because you are passionate about it, or you sell no copies at all.

My illustrator and the characters’ creator doesn’t come from a background in self-publishing, and while I know marginally more than he does, I still don’t know everything. (He thinks we should be the next Mr. Men by now…maybe we should, but I’m afraid that’s not how it works!)

While we’re learning how to best market and produce these books, I thought that it made good sense for me to document some of the things that we’re doing with them. See, one of the problems I have found during my research is that although there is a lot of great advice for self-published children’s book marketing, there’s a gap in the info that pertains specifically to picture books.

Children’s picture paperback book marketing

Ebooks are so popular that most advice is geared towards promoting them, whereas picture books tend to be more popular as a physical book. Think about it. Would you want your toddler’s favorite book to be only accessible via your iPhone or tablet? Probably not.

Traditionally published picture books tend to have a glut of marketing professionals behind them, but indie authors of these types of books have to wing it. And, many self-published authors have grown accustomed to strictly promoting a digital product that people don’t necessarily have to see and hold before they buy it. That doesn’t really work for children’s picture books that don’t have an established reputation and following.

So, I’ll be doing some posts about our marketing methods and strategies, plus I’ll let you know how we do with sales. So far, to be honest, it’s been pretty dismal. But, we’ve recently added three titles to our collection, and we now have five in total. I’m optimistic that we’ll see success, though probably not as quickly or as phenomenally as my partner would like, lol!

Are you a self-published children’s picture book writer? I’d love to hear your comments and tips. I think we’re one group of authors that needs to pull together more to help get these great indie picture books into the little hands that will love them!